Travelers Vs Geico Auto Insurance. Geico ranked as the #1 auto insurer of 2016, with travelers trailing closely behind at #3. The average geico car insurance premium is $37 per month, according to wallethub’s research, while the average farmers car insurance premium is $85 per month.

Geico ranked as the #1 auto insurer of 2016, with travelers trailing closely behind at #3. Choosing a car insurance company can be tricky: Geico and the hartford are two of the biggest names in insurance, with an advertising reach to match.